S = Meritorious Service, B = Bowling Achievement, Bold - Deceased
| Name | Year | For |
| Austin Washington | 2020 | B |
| Gregory Francis, Jr. | 2020 | B |
| David Gilliam | 2018 | S |
| William Toots | 2017 | B |
| Michael Toots | 2017 | B |
| Stephen Atkins | 2017 | B |
| Christine Shiflett | 2016 | S |
| Benjamin Ellis | 2016 | B |
| Teresa Rast | 2016 | B |
| Wayne Toots | 2016 | S |
| Michael McDonald | 2015 | B |
| Jonathan Gist | 2014 | B |
| Clarissa Maddox Bull | 2014 | B |
| Trip Roberts | 2013 | B |
| John "Skip" Robers, Sr. | 2013 | S |
| Alex Dean | 2013 | B |
| Daryl Kimball | 2011 | B |
| Robert Jones, Jr. | 2011 | B |
| Rachael Gittings | 2009 | B |
| Jessica Overton | 2008 | B |
| James Washington, Jr. | 2008 | S |
| Roy Becker | 2008 | B |
| Michael McDonnell | 2006 | B |
| Ged Stilen | 2006 | B |
| George Richards | 2006 | S |
| Ron Conley | 2006 | S |
| James Hamby | 2005 | B |
| John Beasley | 2005 | B |
| Lula Richards | 2005 | S |
| Pat Ely | 2003 | S |
| Dot Proffitt | 2003 | S |
| Bill Seldon | 2000 | S |
| Mildred Fuller | 1999 | S |
